Comments
Wow - this is depressing, maddening, scary, and pure hell for all the patients. Byberry looks like it is abandoned long before it was ever abandoned. There is no way a patient can recover in that environment. Even so many years later, my heart breaks for the patients placed in these "healing" institutions. I know methods were much more primitive then than they are now and they did the best they could with what they had, but these pictures are just unreal. This is like a horror movie looking at these photos! Quite an eye-opener!
TootUncommon
Is there any place where all of Lord's photographs are available for viewing? This is an amazing travesty in America's history, but a fascinating study in the evolution of mental health care. I'm currently reading "The Lives They Left Behind: Suitcases From A State Hospital Attic" and this would be a perfect complementary study.
Rekrats
I saw this story a few weeks back! What those guys did was absolutely incredible. It essentially revolutionized the way these places were operated (to an extent). Even though most of the asylums or state hospitals were still corrupt or shady.

Regardless - still a great group of men. All of them are in their 80's and still alive and kickin'
FahQ
The original LIFE article is here:

http://www.pbs.org/wgb...x/lobotomist/bedlam/
V-
My biggest question now is, where are all these people living now that would otherwise be instatutionalized? Are they in prisons or on the street? I know that there are some resident-type organizations that house people who have mental or other issues in a home like setting (my sister works in one) but they certainly don't house the hundreds or thousands that these hospitals did. So where are all these people going today? It's too bad that they didn't have the knowledge we have now, back then. It may have done some good. PS- THANK YOU for sharing this with us Mr. Motts!
eldokid@aol.com
Wow, thank you for sharing that. How sickening. No wonder poor Lynne has to defend current mental institutions with images like these from the past. What a wonderful thing Lord and the other men did.
Kathy W.
this is amazing. i have an incredible weakness for anything psych. hospital-esque, had to read this... it's comforting to be reminded that for every one asshole who fucks things, there's five nice guys who'll try to fix it, thnx mr. motts:]
m-loc
Eldokid, health care today is more aimed at rehabilitating these people and giving them a place in society instead of dooming everyone to a life inside an institution. There are long term facilities for people who really need that help, say a paranoid schizophrenic who is non-compliant and a threat to others/violent and has been this way for years, ..places exist that provide a therapeutic milieu to help that person stabilize and become a potential contributing member of society so they can live their life independently.. remember not everyone confined to an institution back in the day was actually mentally 'ill' ..some people were brought there because they were poor, or alcoholics, or just a burden to their family, .. or because they disagreed with someone, etc.

Anyways, I love NPR but I missed this so, great post. THanks, man.
EricaM
Interesting to see this posted Motts! I am very familiar with the history of this Life magazine article. Lord and Life did indeed spark national outrage with this material.

For those who may interested, I suggest watching the Frontline episode "The New Asylums" on the PBS web site. There is a followup episode posted for viewing also. PBS will be airing "The Lobotomist" again soon, and it can also be viewed online. The story of Icepick Wally, a true madman.

Eldo: Watch the above Frontlines to see what happens today. Also, back in the 80s, very much federal funding was cut that had helped support many health care institutions. That resulted in the extensive closures and release of patients to fend for themselves. Very many of them simply became the wards of our correctional systems, as shown by Frontline.
autoguy
I believe Geraldo Rivera did an "expose" on the deplorable conditions in state hospitals in the late 60's or early 70's. Some states responsed to this by just letting the patients out and onto the streets. A number of homeless people (this may not be true today) were former "mental institution" patients. I know that there are still state hospitals in existence and assume that conditions have improved exponentailly, but could not venture a guess.
Fla. Gator
Thanks for the link. I'll have to check out the NPR material.

There is a documentary called "The Good War and Those Who Refused to Fight It" that was about the CO experience during WWII. It also goes into detail about the Byberry exposé.
Ŗivẹt
EricaM - You hit the nail on the head with your response!!

Yeah back then you could just be a burden to your family and essentially get "dropped off" at a institution. Then once you're in the system you almost can't help but go crazy; then the downward spiral begins!

Sad times..
FahQ
I believe Geraldo Rivera did an "expose" on the deplorable conditions in state hospitals in the late 60's or early 70's. Some states responsed to this by just letting the patients out and onto the streets. A number of homeless people (this may not be true today) were former "mental institution" patients. I know that there are still state hospitals in existence and assume that conditions have improved exponentailly, but could not venture a guess.
Fla. Gator
As someone who works for a State Department of Mental Health within a hospital I can say that things have really changed from the time that Lord took these photographs. However, for the severely mentally ill person who is involuntarily committed the privations of the inpatient setting, no matter how nice it is, are severe in regards to loss of autonomy, loss of liberty, and basic loss of control over very mundane aspects of one's life (like when and what one eats, taking medication or not, etc.). I am glad these photos exist as a memorial bearing witness to how these people were treated then, but we have a long, long way to go. Thanks Motts--I love this website.
Kathy
Kathy, thank you for your insight. Lynn, what are your thoughts on this ?
FLA GATOR
Thanks for sharing this. Both fascinating and disturbing, I found this guy's story and photographs to be very inspiring. To see, without hindrance, the deplorable and shameful conditions that existed in these places makes you sick, but to know the impact they would have in changing the horrible conditions they portray lends them a certain beauty. They are truly amazing compositions.
Jim O'Connor
Thanks for posting this.
Jenny
That man is a very brave and admirable person...
I would like to think that equality between mentally stable and mentally disabled people exists today, but I know that it doesn't. I hope we don't go back to this...
Tiny
Mennonites are cool
KahunaTony

Comments pertaining to real location names, methods of entering the property, promotions or advertisements, off-topic discussion and general flaming, as well as those submitted under various aliases are subject to immediate deletion and your ip address being banned from this website. By submitting your comment you agree to these terms. Visit the forum for off-topic and general discussion. To prevent your comment from being removed and to help keep this site uncluttered, please read more about comments on opacity.